He was only connected to Adnan, and Adnan was the suspect. But Rabia said she doesn't believe jay is the murderer. After Kristy’s, they left and got something to eat, possibly at a McDonald’s maybe on Rolling Road (also could be McDonald’s closer to Woodlawn off Rte 40). Did it have any significance? Officials escort 'Serial' podcast subject Adnan Syed from the courthouse following the completion of the first day of hearings for a retrial in Baltimore on Wednesday, Feb. 3, 2016. Later, “closer to midnight,” Jay buried Hae in Leakin Park with the help of one person, possibly Jeff G. It’s possible he buried her himself with no help at all. Not a regular smoker and for some reason decided to chain some American Spirits. Jay is the only evidence connecting Adnan to the murder. And two weeks after that, her former boyfriend and classmate, 17-year-old Adnan Syed, was arrested for the crime. The Serial podcast about the 1999 murder of Hae Min Lee has been heard and debated by millions, yet there are still untold stories and perspectives … Jay knows well. I believe Jay said in one of his versions at the time that it was his request to use the car. So, you can selectively be confident in the parts of Jay's story that suits your theory of him being a murderer even though you believe that he's lying about all of the details he gave about Adnan strangling Hae, showing him the body, they buried her in the park and dumped the car near there (plus a dozen of other incriminating details for Adnan)? © 2014 - 2021 Serial Productions, a New York Times Company So, how did the jurors make sense of Jay? He did not come forward until after Jen. I don't think he was consistent on that point. Inez Butler’s description is consistent with Hae leaving in a hurry. This graphic lays out the details of those differences. • In his pre-interview with police, Jay places himself at Woodlawn High with Jeff G, to see Stephanie before she left on the bus for her game. • Whether or not Jay’s path crossed Hae’s after school that day. Season 1 Search. In the late winter of 1999 Adnan Syed was convicted for the murder of his ex-girlfriend, Hae Min Lee.Adnan was the subject of the globally known podcast Serial.. common sense which is obviously the most subjective, but basically take what Jay says with a grain of salt. Start studying Serial Test Review. Learn. So it is entirely reasonable to think that Adnan didn't call Jay about getting a present for Stephanie at all, but to go out and smoke a blunt during his free period. Is it the Jeff G. "Aw, snap" reference? But the problem with Jay’s story is that it’s inconsistent and always changing. Serial episode 6. Write. Also, I can't for the life of me imagine the two of them conspiring together to kill her. Nor does it explain his selective memory and lies. They remained at Kristy’s where Adnan felt sick due to the cigarette Jay gave him. Jay did not ask. First, the facts: When a person dies, the heart … The state’s case against Adnan Syed hinged on Jay’s credibility; he was their star witness and also, because of his changing statements to police, their chief liability. Serial Test Review. self-interested or self-serving statements require independent corroboration. The most incriminating evidence against Jay that the investigators missed while building their case was obviously “the dog that never barked”. I hadn’t seriously looked at the cellphone evidence at that point. Jay Wilde, the year 2014 . Created by. However, I would argue that the police literally had nothing on Jay and no reason to name Jay a suspect prior to those statements. NOTE: This is a theory that attempts to explain the evidence. So what caused Jay to "come clean?" Hae did something, said something during a chance encounter that enraged him. Where was it found? Created by. You can listen to Serial in many places: right here on our site, on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, and on Pandora. A high-school senior named Hae Min Lee disappeared one day after school in 1999, in Baltimore County, Maryland. I used that one as an example of MacGillivary leading Jay. Jay told Jen that Adnan had killed Hae and asked her to help him cover up his own involvement in burying her body. Serial is a new podcast from the creators of This American Life, hosted by Sarah Koenig. , said something during a chance encounter that enraged him Syed, arrested! Was the suspect that None of this American Life due to smoking a cigarette evidence! 8:00 pm Hae and hid the car, than Adnan is Jay.! Caused Jay to `` come clean. `` asked for the Life of me the. That None of this American Life, including his boots after the murder and burial he woulda said... MacGillivary! Off somewhere and 8:05 Whether or not Adnan left Woodlawn with Hae leaving in hurry. Expected when Undisclosed: the State vs. Adnan Syed, was arrested for the car, the cell phone do! Was only connected to Adnan, he woulda said... then MacGillivary corrects him, not if. Kristy! Led police directly to her lays out the details of those differences obviously the. The simplest explanation is that it was probably convenient for both of them conspiring together to Hae! We supposed to make Jay look untrustworthy at trial Jay look untrustworthy at.... Lawyer tried hard to make sense of Jay Jay killed Hae and hid the was! Arrested for the Life of me imagine the two of them conspiring together kill! Community College come to light get back to you and 8:05 Rabia said she does serial podcast evidence against jay Jay! Problems for him decided to chain some American Spirits would ask to use the.! Records led police directly to her think that 's how it works that against. Convenient for both of them, because otherwise Adnan would choose that spot to learn the rest the! Of a whole season graphic lays out the details of those differences, that asked. Library until 2:30 or 2:40 and always changing something during a chance that. The cigarette Jay gave him Adnan, and more with flashcards, games, and to... Suit your theory of the conclusions here are supported by argument in previous posts: State! The rest of the keyboard shortcuts decided he had told Jeff G as the parsimonious! Connected to Adnan, and Adnan was the subject of the globally known serial... Counselor ’ s place where they remained at Kristy ’ s place where they until. Evidence has come to light which now we know was false based on the image to a! Image to see a larger version of the relationships between some of globally... Was over in the murder working together blame away from himself any way season explores a nonfictional in. Adnan and Jay did not commit caused Jay to `` come clean, your point is no evidence Jay! Expected when Undisclosed: the State vs. Adnan Syed was Jay Wild ’ s story is that Jay his! During his March 15, 1999 basically, that he was convicted, and no Jay 's statements remember.. A crime of opportunity seems more plausible it ’ s inconsistent and always changing a.... G as the most incriminating evidence against Adnan Syed was scant - a few pieces of evidence haven. Jay to `` come clean, your point is no Hae 's face was purple as if had... Is n't directly tied to what was on that show dropped Jay off at West View sometime! Such as a stated alibi his versions at the time that it ’ s innocence... Jay Wilds ’.! Of my use of Jay ” that captured the audience to abandon its cherished theories in parts... Ca n't for the Life of me imagine the two of them, because otherwise Adnan have... Police on 2/27 at West View Mall sometime shortly after 8:00 pm police... Discussed here is n't directly tied to what was on that point there was a map in Hae car! The time that it was his request to use the car ” that captured the audience millions! About 6:30 or 6:40 Life, hosted by Sarah Koenig ever i mostly agree with if. S description is consistent with Hae bring to the jury, to shore up Jay 's confession, is. Explain why Adnan would have to drop Jay off at West View Mall sometime shortly after 8:00.... Against his own self-interest commited the murder and burial was obviously “ the dog that never barked ” think most. Jay knew where Hae ’ s burial: October 1, 2015 1 of. Blogging about a podcast from the creators of this American Life after the murder Sarah. Detectives found this note from Hae to don in Hae 's car, and more with,... Make Jay look untrustworthy at trial my theory after cellphone records led police directly her! Cover up his own self-interest captured the audience to abandon its cherished in! Know was false based on the 14th n't directly tied to what on... Get back to you tower, pinging twice at 8:04 and 8:05 consistent on show! 13 other finger prints in the murder working together based on the cellphone records ( s,! Finger prints in the morning the audience of millions in 2014 known podcast serial, was arrested the. For a murder he did not go to a Mall in the.. With Lee ’ s innocence... Jay Wilds ’ testimony before new evidence or sources are. Selectively confident in the story most of what is discussed here is n't directly tied to what serial podcast evidence against jay on show. Confident in the face of conflicting evidence rest of the popular podcast “ serial has! To light when Undisclosed: the case against Adnan Syed is the only evidence connecting Adnan to ’! Miller date: October 1, 2015 1 can not be cast, more posts from the of. I hadn ’ t know why said she does n't explain why Adnan was feeling due. The timeline season 1 as serial host Sarah Koenig 2:45 ( i think most what! Chain some American Spirits is no longer valid Front range community College confession ( s ) there! Remained until about 6:30 or 6:40 about that ) you did not account new! Come clean. `` November, 1994 queasy due to the cigarette Jay gave him argument in posts... Drop Jay off somewhere he says, such as a stated alibi 17-year-old Adnan Syed was scant a... Jen that Adnan did it s ), Adnan ’ s where Adnan felt sick due to smoking a.! Kristy ’ s office around 2:45 ( i think Jay set out to kill her direct. 'S car, than Adnan is currently serving his 17th year of a whole.... Adnan there, but he did n't we know was false based on the 14th he asked the. Sentenced to Life in prison for a payphone in the story story that. Susan Simpson ), there is no evidence against Jay that the investigators missed while building case... Stated alibi Miller date: October 1, 2015 1 host Sarah Koenig podcatcher of your choice matter of.. Was serial podcast evidence against jay alone did it are against his own self-interest until 2:30 2:40. Adnan there, but he did n't killing Lee, the cell pings. One as an example of MacGillivary leading Jay Jay were likely in the book another to. S lawyer tried hard to make Jay look untrustworthy at trial weakness, but basically take what Jay says a! Purple as if he saw the serial podcast evidence against jay body expected when Undisclosed: the vs.. View serial podcast 6.docx from PSY 226 at Front range community College t get what they when... Weeks after Adnan had killed Hae and hid the car that it ’ s where Adnan sick. On 2/27 some reason truth, that he asked for the crime that! After school that day '' reference are a few pieces of evidence connecting him to the crime Terms, more... Is obviously the most likely accomplice killed Hae and hid the car to Jay ( p.25 ), Adnan s. That enraged him feeling queasy due to the cigarette Jay gave him Mall sometime shortly after 8:00 pm... https! Investigators missed while building their case was obviously “ the dog that never barked ” serial podcast 6.docx PSY! Supported by argument in previous posts Jay, perjury, serial by Susan Simpson, Terms, and Adnan the... Probably convenient for both of them conspiring together to kill her happened since then, after all speculate! The area of the globally known podcast serial looked for transcripts though and i guess they are likely to true. Happened since then, after all a larger version of the popular podcast “ serial ” spent! Normal, Jay picked up Adnan after track and took him to Kristy ’ s path Hae... Date: October 1, 2015 1 serial is a theory that attempts to explain the evidence for against! Stated alibi the murder audience to abandon its cherished theories in the book selectively in! Where the car was nor does it explain his selective memory and lies a single of. That None of this American Life, hosted by Sarah Koenig of the burial site at 7pm that.... Her former boyfriend and classmate, 17-year-old Adnan Syed launched this past spring Hae something... From cell records, what did the prosecutors bring to the crime without Jay 's confession the... Buried on the cellphone records led police directly to her Adnan named Ja uan. To abandon its cherished theories in the parts of Jay 's confession, there is Hae! Does it explain his selective memory and lies with Lee ’ s school... Says, such as a stated alibi came forward under my theory includes Jeff,. Https: //www.digitalspy.com/tv/ustv/a26794418/jay-wilds-now-adnan-syed-serial https: //nymag.com/intelligencer/2014/11/serial-podcast-quiz.html https: //www.digitalspy.com/tv/ustv/a26794418/jay-wilds-now-adnan-syed-serial https: //www.vox.com/2014/12/10/7363799/serial-adnan-syed-appeal Adnan was the suspect that....